Accessibility links

Breaking News

Lawyers Challenging Mnangagwa’s Decision to Extend Chief Justice’s Term of Office


FILE: Zimbabwean President Emmerson Mnangagwa,left, is congratulated by Chief Justice Luke Malaba after taking his oath during his inauguration ceremony at the National Sports Stadium in Harare, Sunday, Aug. 26, 2018.

HARARE, May 13 (Reuters) – Zimbabwe’s High Court will on Friday hear preliminary arguments in a case in which lawyers are challenging the extension of Chief Justice Luke Malaba’s term of office.

President Emmerson Mnangagwa extended the tenure of the chief justice by five years following contentious changes to the constitution that allowed for the extension and are being challenged in court by lawyers.

Malaba had been due to retire on Saturday when he turns 70, but Mnangagwa's ruling ZANU-PF party used its majority in parliament to amend the constitution, allowing the president to extend the retirement age of senior judges to 75 years if they proved they were in good health.

In a statement, the chief secretary to the cabinet said Mnangagwa had accepted a medical report from Malaba, which showed the top judge had the "mental and physical fitness to continue in that office".

But lawyers and the opposition say the amendment that allowed Malaba to continue in office and empower Mnangagwa to appoint judges of the Constitutional and Supreme Courts rather than go through public interviews was a violation of the country's charter.

They argue that under the constitution, changes to term limits require a referendum and that incumbents do not benefit from such changes. But the government says it only changed the retirement age and so did not breach the supreme law.

In court papers, the lawyers have cited the justice minister, Malaba and all the 16 judges of the Constitutional and Supreme Court as respondents in the case. The judges oppose the court challenge.

Some legal experts say Zimbabwe could be heading towards a constitutional crisis. If the High Court dismisses the case and the lawyers appeal, they will have to face the very same judges they have cited in their court challenge. (Reporting by MacDonald Dzirutwe Editing by Gareth Jones)

Facebook Forum

XS
SM
MD
LG